|
Violent
Crimes
Prison Issues


Governor's
move sends California into new prison territory
By
Mason Stockstill, Staff Writer
Associated Press
Article Launched:10/06/2006
CHINO - Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger's recent declaration of an emergency
in state prisons will mean two new possibilities for inmates at the California
Institution for Men and other prisons: doing time at private prisons and
doing time in other states.
Criminal
Neglect Schwarzenegger's proclamation makes it possible for California
to contract for prison beds with private operators in other states - a
proposal the governor had sought earlier this year but was rebuffed by
the Legislature.
"Our
prisons are now beyond maximum capacity, and we must act immediately and
aggressively to resolve this issue," he said Wednesday.
But
experts questioned the wisdom of the move, noting that placing prisoners
in out-of-state facilities has in the past led to violence.
"There's
been lots of problems with inmates being shipped out, in particular if
they're put into a facility with multijurisdictional inmates," said
Ken Kopczynski, of the Florida-based Private Corrections Institute. "California
inmates are under California law. If they have Oklahoma inmates, or Texas
inmates, they all have to be handled separately."
Disparity
in treatment of prisoners from several states was one cause identified
in a 2004 riot where inmates alternately smashed, flooded and torched
a private institution in Colorado, Kopczynski noted.
In that incident, prisoners from different states -Colorado, Washington
and Wyoming - felt they were being treated unfairly, since each state
paid different wages for inmate labor.
Other
problems can arise when inmates from different states get together to
form their own gangs, or when the distance from their families and support
networks is too great, making rehabilitation less likely.
Kopczynski
also said the private corrections industry has racked up a less-than-stellar
record in the past, mostly due to cost-saving efforts such as using low-wage
guards and cutting corners on security.
At a media briefing, James Tilton, the secretary of California's Department
of Corrections and Rehabilitation, said he is close to signing contracts
with private operators in four states: Arizona, Indiana, Oklahoma and
Tennessee.
Those
facilities could house 2,200 inmates total - a drop in the bucket compared
to California's total of 172,000.
Still,
Tilton said as many as 16,000 California inmates are living in what are
called "bad beds," meaning they're set up in gymnasiums, hallways
and other makeshift environments. To relieve that overcrowding, the department
last month sent a survey to inmates, asking if they would consider serving
their sentence in another state.
More
than 19,000 inmates indicated they'd be open to the idea, but the actual
number who are shipped elsewhere will be lower, Tilton said.
Schwarzenegger's
proclamation also makes it possible to involuntarily ship inmates to out-of-state
locations. The governor had sought a similar plan earlier this year during
a special legislative session aimed at addressing the state's prison crisis.
The Legislature, however, did not pass a single bill during the special
session.
The
Associated Press contributed to this report.
Mason Stockstill can be reached by e-mail at mason.stockstill@dailybulletin.com,
or by phone at (909) 483-9354.
***
California
Prison Population
A
Look At Who’s Behind Bars
May Offer Clues On How To Fix Problems
By
Public Policy Institute of California
Amanda Bailey and Joseph Hayes, research associates
This opinion article appeared in the San Diego Union-Tribune August 31,
2007
California
prisons are in crisis. Inmates are dying at an unusually high rate, rehabilitation
programs are minimal, and a federal receiver has taken control of the
prison health care system.
Prisons are
severely overcrowded –- with 173,000 prisoners sleeping in gyms,
dayrooms and classrooms and state prison facilities will likely run out
of space by this time next year. California has the highest recidivism
rate in the country: 70 percent of prisoners are re-imprisoned within
three years.
In response,
state leaders are debating next steps and struggling to develop a strategy
to fix the system. Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger has proposed large-scale
construction of new prisons and generated widespread opposition in the
process; a special session of the Legislature has met to grapple with
the construction issue and to evaluate whether the governor's plan includes
adequate rehabilitation and other alternatives to construction.
While it's
true that action is needed, but may not be forthcoming soon, the short-term
decisions by policy-makers could lead us down a faulty and expensive path.
An essential ingredient to solving the massive prisons problem is to take
a breather and understand the population at the center of the debate:
a group that has been growing at three times the rate of California's
overall population for the last 15 years.
What's different
about California prisoners today? For one, despite policies such as “Three
Strikes and You're Out,” which have lengthened inmates' sentences
and the time they serve, more and more prisoners are cycling repeatedly
through the system.
In 2004,
two-thirds (67 percent) of admissions to state prisons were returning
inmates, a jump from 59 percent in 1990. Prisoners are being returned
either for technical violations of their parole or for new crimes, which
contributes to the 70 percent recidivism rate.
The current
parole system increases the likelihood that parolees will return to prison.
The state doesn't use any intermediate level punishment; if you violate
parole, you go back to prison, no matter how minor the violation.
Furthermore,
this is a tremendous administrative burden: of those 173,000 prisoners,
about 120,000 are admitted in and 120,000 released out of the system throughout
the year.
Any thoughtful
solution to the state's prisons crisis should realistically consider the
effect this type of turnover has on the communities, neighborhoods and
families from which prisoners come, and to which many eventually return.
For example,
two-thirds of women and over half of men in prison are parents of minor
children and children of incarcerated parents have been found to be more
likely to serve prison time themselves.
Overcrowding
has curtailed rehabilitation efforts because of space and budget constraints,
so released prisoners return to their neighborhoods without the skills
to make it on the outside. Too often, they subsequently commit a violation
of their parole, or a new crime, at the expense of their communities and
families, and return to the prison system, at the expense of California
taxpayers.
Studies show
that prisoners who earn a GED in prison are less likely to return to prison.
California's prison population is also aging rapidly. In 1990, 20 percent
of the prison population was under age 25; by the end of 2005, this group
made up only 14 percent of prisoners.
During the
same period, the share of prisoners age 50 and older nearly tripled, from
4 percent to 11 percent. Given the state of health care in California
prisons, these trends have critical implications.
Researchers
have estimated the cost of housing, transporting and caring for elderly
prisoners to be two to three times higher than for other prisoners.
Inmates are
aging because the state's overall population is aging, but also, policies
have lengthened prisoners' sentences and the amount of time they serve,
so they age while incarcerated. Also,
older adults are increasingly likely to go to prison.
As costs
mount, cost-effective alternatives to incarcerating older people who are
statistically less likely to pose a threat to society may become a prudent
consideration. Decision-makers charged with reforming the prison system
should consider the characteristics of the prison population before implementing
policies that would affect it.
The changing
demographics of prisoners can provide valuable clues as to the origin
of rising costs and unchecked growth, and perhaps informed decisions on
whether to emphasize deterrence, rehabilitation or warehousing, in crafting
a coherent corrections policy.
All Contents © Public Policy Institute of California
2003, 2004, 2005, 2007
***
Inmates
proud to earn diplomas behind bars
By
Charles F. Bostwick, Staff Writer
L.A. Daily News
10/06/2006
LANCASTER
- Thirteen men in graduation gowns and caps walked up to a podium Friday
to receive diplomas and shake hands with dignitaries - but these weren't
typical graduates.
These
were men locked up behind electrified fences and barbed wire, some for
life for crimes like murder, men who earned their high school equivalency
diplomas - and in one case, a college associate degree.
"For
myself and for a lot of prisoners, the idea of advancing ourselves and
doing better, that's something a lot of prisoners share," said Kenneth
Hartman, 45, who dropped out of eighth grade and has been in prison for
nearly 27 years, since a drunken, drugged-up beating that killed a homeless
man in a Long Beach park.
From
California State Prison-Los Angeles County's Honor Yard - for inmates
who've sworn off violence, gangs and drugs - Hartman earned an associate
degree from Coastline Community College.
Hartman studied by correspondence courses and watched classes on an Orange
County public-television station. He'd like to go for his bachelor's degree
but says the fees and other expenses would cost him $10,000 to $15,000.
The
dozen other men who earned their general equivancy diplomas passed the
GED test in April, getting together in cellblock day rooms to help one
another learn subjects like math, grammar, science and social studies,
prison academic instructor Bert Fisher said.
"When
I was young, I said I was going to graduate from high school and I was
going to go on to college. I was going to go on to do the best I could
with my life," said inmate Jimmie Gilmer, the class valedictorian.
"But sometimes things change in life, and we all took detours to
get here. I want to step closer to completing what I told my younger self
I would."
The
13-year-old prison holds some 4,500 inmates, more than twice what it was
designed for - though ever since its 1993 opening, it has had two men
in each one-person cell. Now inmates also sleep in bunks set up in gymasiums
and cellblock day rooms.
More
than 150 inmates are taking academic classes, teachers said, and others
take vocational classes in trades like plumbing and masonry. About 15
are taking college classes.
"
The department is changing. We're kind of going away from the warehousing
to the rehabiliation," acting Warden Robert Wong said.
Besides
the 13 graduates from the Honor Yard, there were an additional 43 from
a second prison yard earning high school diplomas and vocational certificates.
The
Honor Yard graduation ceremony featured entertainment by inmate musicians,
including a vocal quartet whose four members included former professional
vocalist Eric Davis, who performed in Las Vegas and toured the U.S. with
an opening act for the 1970s soul group The Delfonics.
The
Honor Yard, created in 2000, holds inmates who apply to be there. They
must be without disciplinary problems for three to five years, agree to
random drug tests and swear off gang activity.
Copyright
2007 by WJFA. All rights reserved. The material on this web site may not
be copied, published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. See WJFA's
Disclaimer and Privacy
Policy. |